Just an update. Pretty bummed but it is what it is.
I am still rubbing even after getting my front fenders rolled. Its a lot less but going over certain bumps/crevices it happens or hitting turns at a good amount of speed. Found out I am rubbing slightly in the rear too on the passenger side. Rubber getting stuck up in the rear fender and I am not that low at all. As you can see:
So I did some research to compare the sizes with a tire calculator I found online.
Tire Size Comparison | Comparison of tires and wheels
Comparing my current 235/45/17 to a 225/45/17
Tire diameter:25.3 inch 25 inch
Sidewall height:4.2 inch 4 inch
Rolling circum: 79.6 inch 78.5 inch
Would .3'' be enough to help out?
Another size I saw a member running on BC coilovers and the same size RPF1's (17x8 +35).. 245/40/17
Tire diameter: 25.3 inch 24.7 inch
Sidewall height: 4.2 inch 3.9 inch
Rolling circum: 79.6 inch 77.6 inch
So .6'' more clearance with that size. Which is what I am leaning towards in getting.
Ride height difference -0.31 inch. Not sure if that matters or not when it comes to rubbing because my car will sit lower with the 245/40 it looks like.