I'd say atleast 90% of the returnline setups out there today are after the rail...can't say that I've even seen one before the rail on an srt yet. Anyways, yeah it does make sense to me to have it after the rail to be on the safe side but it's hard to say wether that's actually practical or if we're just being over cautious. With the regulator, I think the problem would be your pressure. If there is no stopping point for the fuel i.e. it just goes in a loop, it would be hard to keep a constant pressure that way. the fuel may just fly straight through the rail and won't give enough time for the injectors to pull the fuel into the manifold...just seems kinda logical to me that way...but hopefully someone with some more experience can chime in on that